Could DOGE Become a Government Agency with Elon Musk as a Secretary?

Ngosugar [email protected] November 13, 2024 | 14:49

The recent creation of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) and Elon Musk’s leadership role has fueled speculation about its future. Could DOGE evolve into a formal government agency? If so, would Elon Musk transition from an advisor to a Cabinet-level Secretary?

This article explores these questions through the lens of legal precedents, political dynamics, and current realities under the Republican-controlled Congress.

Learn more: How Will Elon Musk Run DOGE?

Elon Musk as Secretary?

The Legal Path to Becoming a Government Agency

For DOGE to become an official government agency, certain legal and constitutional steps must be taken:

1. Congressional Authorization

Under the U.S. Constitution, new federal departments or agencies can only be established through legislation. Congress would need to draft, debate, and pass a bill formally creating DOGE as a federal agency. This law would outline its mission, authority, budget, and organizational structure.

2. Presidential Approval

Once Congress passes the legislation, the President must sign it into law. Given President Trump’s enthusiasm for DOGE and his alignment with Republican legislators, this step is likely to be a formality if the legislation reaches his desk.

3. Budget Appropriation

As a formal agency, DOGE would require funding through the federal budget, which Congress must approve annually. This would subject DOGE to the same budgetary scrutiny as other departments, such as the Department of Energy or Department of Education.

Learn more: Elon Musk Heads DOGE: Secretary or Advisor?

Political Dynamics Favoring DOGE’s Formalization

Currently, the Republican Party holds majorities in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. This political alignment provides a favorable environment for DOGE to be formalized into a government agency.

Here’s why:

1. Republican Support for Efficiency Initiatives

The GOP has long advocated for smaller, more efficient government. DOGE’s mission aligns closely with this ideology, making it a natural fit for Republican priorities.

2. Trump’s Influence on the Party

President Trump’s support for DOGE and Elon Musk could galvanize Republican lawmakers to champion its formalization. Trump’s endorsement carries significant weight within the party, particularly in a unified government scenario.

3. Musk’s Popularity Across Party Lines

Elon Musk’s reputation as an innovative entrepreneur appeals to both Republicans and Democrats. His involvement could attract bipartisan support, making it easier to pass the necessary legislation.

Learn more: What is the DOGE, and Who Will Lead It?

Challenges to DOGE Becoming a Government Agency

Despite the favorable conditions, there are obstacles to DOGE’s formalization:

1. Resistance to Expanding Government

Some Republican lawmakers might oppose creating a new agency, viewing it as contradictory to the party’s goal of reducing government size.

2. Funding Debates

Securing federal funding for DOGE could prove contentious. Critics might question whether its efficiency goals justify its cost, especially if private funding mechanisms are already in place.

3. Democratic Opposition

Democrats may view DOGE’s creation as a politically motivated move and resist its formalization. Concerns about transparency, potential conflicts of interest, and the role of private influence in public governance could fuel opposition.

Would Elon Musk Become a Secretary?

If DOGE were formalized, Elon Musk could theoretically become a Cabinet-level Secretary. However, several factors would influence this transition:

1. Senate Confirmation

To become a Secretary, Musk would need to undergo Senate confirmation. While Republicans currently control the Senate, Musk’s unconventional background and outspoken views could lead to a contentious confirmation process.

2. Willingness to Serve

Musk’s role as a Secretary would require him to leave his private-sector ventures or place them in a blind trust, as federal conflict-of-interest laws prohibit Cabinet members from actively managing private businesses. It is unclear whether Musk would be willing to make such a sacrifice.

3. Public Perception

Musk’s transition to a government role could spark debates about the blending of private enterprise and public service. While his supporters might view him as a transformative leader, critics could raise concerns about his qualifications for a government position.

Both pro and con views were expressed in response to Musk's X post soliciting public opinion on whether he should join the Trump administration.

Legal and Historical Precedents

Historical Creation of Federal Departments

The U.S. government has a history of creating new departments to address emerging challenges. For example:

♦ The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) was established in 2002 following the 9/11 attacks.

♦ The Department of Education was created in 1979 to address national education policy.

These examples demonstrate that creating a new department is possible but requires broad political and public support.

Private Sector Leaders in Government Roles

There is precedent for private-sector leaders transitioning to government roles. For example:

♦ Rex Tillerson, former CEO of ExxonMobil, served as Secretary of State.

♦ Andrew Mellon, a financier and industrialist, served as Secretary of the Treasury in the 1920s.

If Musk were nominated as Secretary of DOGE, his private-sector experience would not disqualify him but could become a focal point during confirmation hearings.

Public Concerns and Ethical Considerations

1. Transparency

If DOGE becomes a government agency, it would need to adhere to federal transparency laws, such as the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). This would subject its operations to public scrutiny, addressing concerns about its current reliance on private funding.

2. Conflicts of Interest

Musk’s extensive business interests in technology and infrastructure could create perceived or actual conflicts of interest. As a government official, he would need to divest from or recuse himself from decisions involving his companies.

3. Accountability

As an advisory body, DOGE operates with minimal oversight. If it transitions into a formal agency, it would be subject to the same accountability mechanisms as other departments, including audits and congressional oversight.

Conclusion: Secretary or Advisor?

While the current political landscape favors the potential formalization of DOGE, significant hurdles remain. Turning DOGE into a formal government agency would require legislative action, bipartisan support, and public backing.

Elon Musk’s role as a visionary advisor suits DOGE’s current status as an independent advisory body. However, if DOGE evolves into a Cabinet-level department, Musk’s potential nomination as Secretary would hinge on his willingness to embrace the constraints of public service and navigate the complexities of Senate confirmation.

For now, DOGE’s innovative structure and Musk’s leadership represent a bold experiment in bridging private-sector innovation and public-sector efficiency. Whether it will grow into a permanent institution with Musk at its helm remains a question for Congress, the administration, and the American people.

Facts about Elon Musk Sending Dodgecoin-Funded Satellite to the Moon

Elon Musk may not have sent dogecoin’s price to the moon with his “Saturday Night Live” appearance, but his SpaceX will accept the cryptocurrency ...

Who is the Father of Elon Musk: Biography, Personal Life, Career, Net Worth

Errol Musk is a South African electromechanical engineer, pilot, sailor, and property developer. Check out this biography to know about his biography: his childhood, family, ...